SCOTUS hears case of Missouri man too sick for lethal injection


On Tuesday, the U.S. Supreme Court heard oral argument in the case of 50-year-old Russell Bucklew, a Missouri death row prisoner who came within a few hours of his execution in March when the Court granted a stay, in a 5-4 decision, to give it time to study his appeal. Bucklew suffers from cavernous hemangioma, a rare medical condition that causes blood-filled tumors in his head, throat and lips. Because of this, his lawyers argue that if the state executes him by lethal injection, Bucklew will choke to death on his own blood because his veins are so compromised by his condition. They argued that if the execution has to go forward the state should use lethal gas, specifically nitrogen, instead of lethal injection 

At Tuesday’s argument, Bucklew’s attorney, Robert Hochman, told the justices that he isn’t objecting to lethal injection because he’s anticipating there will be problems with the procedure — “I’m assuming everything’s going to go exactly the way they intend it” — he’s objecting because Bucklew’s condition is such that even “If everything goes according to plan, there is constitutionally significant suffering.”

State Solicitor D. John Sauer argued against the alternative of lethal gas, saying it’s never been tested or used in another execution, and was suggested as a delaying tactic — “The goal is to have challenge after challenge after challenge” — and that Bucklew would have had a “stronger case” if he had asked for electrocution or firing squad. And as to whether there would be “significant suffering,” Sauer responded, “We vigorously dispute the suggestion that he’s presented any competent evidence that he actually will experience something like a prolonged drowning.”

There was some concurrence among Court observers that the questioning by the justices fell along ideological lines, although Amy Howe, in Scotusblog, wrote that “It seemed very possible that the outcome could hinge on the vote of the court’s newest justice, Brett Kavanaugh, who at times appeared sympathetic to Bucklew.”

You might also be interested in...

The tragic case of Kevin Johnson, set to be killed by Missouri this month

Missouri killed Kevin Johnson on Tuesday evening. He was sentenced to death for killing Kirkwood police officer Sgt. William McEntee...
Read More

Tennessee’s shameful and shocking treatment of Henry Hodges

A judge’s order late last month means a man on Tennessee’s death row, who slit his wrists before severing his...
Read More

Oklahoma high court denies both of Glossip’s petitions for a hearing on new evidence

In one week, the Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals denied two petitions filed by Richard Glossip for an evidentiary hearing...
Read More